The World of Work in a Changing Cuba

01 January 2008

Cuba Si
The magazine of CSC
Dr Steve Ludlam reports on how unions and government are working together to reduce income inequalities and corruption in employment
Winter 2015
All in this together: Cuba's Participatory Democracy
A Victory for Cuba – but it’s not over yet
Regime change: time to try another tactic
Autumn 2014
Cubans first to support Sierra Leone ebola fight
US contracts Latin American youth for subversion in Cuba

What about the workers?
Summer 2014
“Now we have air!”
Something is moving
Gerardo: Saturday night parties and what I never realised
Cuban Day against Homophobia
Spring 2014
Bacardi - supporting the blockade since 1962
Global campaigners unite in London for the Five
Focus on Haiti
Winter 2013-14
Rediscovering Celia Sánchez
Final destination Havana for London cab
We do not fold our arms: Mandela and Cuba
Autumn 2013
Latin America Conference and Fiesta Latina!
Winter 2012
Inspiration from last year's Latin America Conference
Autumn 2012
Blind Cubans Going to the Movies
ALBA – The Bolivarian Alliance for the Peoples of our America
The Greatest Pain for a Father
Autumn 2012
Part II - Interview with Ricardo Alarcon, President of the Cuban Parliament
Summer 2012
An interview with Ricardo Alarcon, President of the Cuban Parliament
A revolutionary train of thought
Keeping AIDS at Bay in Cuba
Spring 2012
Sport at the heart of revolution
Summer 2011
Restructuring the Revolution
Breaking the Silence: Beyond the Frame- Contemporary Cuban Art
A socialist path to sustainability
A manufactured dissident
Spring 2011
In Santiago it is always the 26th
50 years of solidarity
Revealing Che’s revolutionary roots
The Doctors’ Revolution
Winter 2011
Gerardo remains positive
Playa Girón
Habana Hoy: The New Sound of Cuban Music
Latin lessons: What can we learn from the world’s most ambitious literacy campaign?
Autumn 2010
La revolucion energetica: Cuba's energy revolution
Daughter of Cuba
Sustaining the revolution
Cuba and the number of “political prisoners”
Summer 2010
Noam Chomsky on Cuba-US relations - exclusive
Friends of Cuba Solidarity Campaign
Miami 5 updates
Waste not, want not
Spring 2010
Concert for Haiti
Cubans in Haiti
Remedios y sus Parrandas
The real war on terror
Auntumn 2009
Interview with families of the Five
Autumn 2009
Juan Almeida Bosque – hero of the revolution
Presidio Modelo, School of Revolutionaries
Summer 2009
From here to there - Interview with Omar Puente
Talking to Aleida Guevara
Ken Gill ‘son of Cuba’
Pride in Cuba
Cuba50 - 40,000 people join the celebrations
Spring 2009
A chance encounter with Operación Milagro
Confronting rhetoric with reality
Talking about a Revolution
Pushing for a change in UK policy
Winter 2008-9
The revolution that defies the laws of gravity
Feminising the Revolution
Hasta La Victoria Siempre - Interview with Cuban poet who witnessed Revolution
Autumn 2008
TUC Congress reports
Terror in Miami - Cuba's exile community
After the storm - Hurricane report
Families torn apart - Miami 5 interview
Summer 2008
AGM Report - CSC celebrates year’s successes
Miami Five – Ten years on
Changes in Cuba?
Havana rights
Spring 2008
Celebrating 50 years of progress
Fidel stands down
Libraries at the heart of the community
Lessons for a greener world
Cuba50 – Celebrating Cuban Culture
Winter 2007/08
“In every barrio, Revolution!” - CDR Museum opens
Fighting for the Five - Leonard Weinglass interview
The World of Work in a Changing Cuba
Campaign on Barclays and extraterritoriality continues…
Autumn 2007
21st century medicine
The living legacy of Che
Interviewing Fidel
Summer 2007
Farewell to Vilma:
From Pakistan to Rotherham:
Whose rules rule?
Spring 2007
Feeding the revolution
Stop the Hilton Hotels ban
Teaching citizenship the Cuban way
Winter 06/07
Exclusive: London's Mayor visits Cuba (inglés y espanol)
Rendezvous with lies
World Circuit Records celebrates 20 years
Autumn 2006
America's favourite immigrants
Life without Fidel
The landing of the Granma
Summer 2006
Teatro Miramar: a dream to be realised
Bush’s ‘secret’ plan for Cuba
From Cuba with love: Cuban doctors in Pakistan
Spring 2006
“Hombres not Nombres”
Exporting healthcare: Cuba and the real meaning of internationalism
Let there be Light
Winter 2005-6
Confessions of an “independent” trade unionist
Europe partakes in a recipe for disaster cooked up in Washington
We are stronger than ever
Autumn 2005
Education from womb to tomb
Brendan Barber pledges TUC support for Cuba
Five reasons why the people rule
Summer 2005
Bill and Joe’s Cuban cycle adventure
Poet of Guantanamo
Participation is key to Cuba’s democracy
Spring 2005
Trip of a lifetime
Justice delayed, justice denied
Is Venezuela next after Iraq?
Winter 2004/5
Cuba's Response to AIDS
Books: Bulwark against neo-liberalism
Guide to the `Report from the Commission for Assistance to a Free Cuba´
Autumn 2004
Book review: Cuba’s story
Autumn 2004
Heart strings
Speaking truth to power: Cuba at the UN
Summer 2004
Cuba saved my daughter
Salud International to back Cuban internationalist doctors
A revolution in culture
Spring 2004
Biotech for all
US occupation of Guantanamo Bay is illegal, says top lawyer
Miami Five: Hopeful of justice
Winter 2003/4
Solar-powered education
Charting women’s progress since 1959
The truth about Reporters Sans Frontières
Autumn 2003
Does the FCO website betray a political bias against Cuba?
Join the CSC bike ride to Cuba
How the US stole Guantanamo Bay
Summer 2003
Hands Off Cuba Campaign Launched
Monument to freedom
UK lawyer visits Havana
EU lines up with US
Ibrahim Ferrer: a lesson in greatness
The Miami Five -an injustice too far
My secret mission to meet Fidel
Spring 2003
Cuban student tours UK
Beyond the beach and sun:
CSC’s Father Geoff Bottoms visits one of the Five
Autumn 2002
British credit cards hit by US sanctions
Housing for the People
Moncada Day Cycle Challenge
Summer 2002
Evil Spirit
From May Day In Havana To The Cradle Of The Revolution
A dream for all times
How foreigners fuel US anti-Cuba policy
Spring 2002
How the US planned to start a war with Cuba
Toys for Cuba
Welsh Education Minister meets Fidel
Winter 2013-14
Final destination Havana for London cab
The World of Work in a Changing Cuba
While commentators have been pre-occupied with Fidel’s illness and the prospects of change under Raul, there has been less attention to changes already happening in the Cuban economy, especially in employment relations and union rights. These are key indicators of Cuba’s socialism as it develops in a world of ruthless capitalism.

The Special Period, of measures to overcome the Soviet collapse and renewed US hostility, is officially not over. However, in spite of the tightened US blockade, the Cuban economy has restored its pre-crisis GNP, based on the success of strategic sectors of the Special Period, notably tourism and Cuba’s ‘knowledge economy’ in health, education and science. But, and it is a big but for Cubans, the pre-crisis distribution of incomes has not recovered. As every visitor to Cuba knows, and as Cuban leaders repeatedly stress, the Special Period, with its ‘dollarisation’, remittances from relatives in the USA, western tourists, self-employment and partial marketisation of agricultural produce, has undermined equality in Cuba, both socially, and especially in terms of income distribution. Less measurable has been the impact on everyday ethics, with the population having to boost legal incomes by odd-jobbing and trading in the informal sector, often with material pinched from work.

State workers, for example in health and education, and indeed government ministers, are paid on the modest national peso scales. Most have limited opportunities to earn anything on the side or in Cuba’s ‘hard’ currency, the CUC. The CUCs are needed in the informal sector and in the well-stocked CUC stores, which sell at ‘western’ prices, enabling Cuba to ‘farm’ hard currency to pay for vital imports. Those who can afford something in these shops, are those get CUCs in salary bonuses, from tourist tips, self-employment, remittances, or from informal or illegal trading. A few constitute the ‘new rich’ attacked by Fidel, some of whom have no need to work at all, something most Cubans find shocking and immoral.

Since Fidel’s much-cited November 2005 speech lambasting corruption and black markets, Cuba’s unions have prioritised the fight against workplace fiddling. But union leaders point out that until legal salaries once again give people a decent income, this is an uphill struggle. It is in this context that Raul, in his 26 July speech, admitted bluntly that ordinary salaries were ‘insufficient to satisfy all necessities’. Nor, he said, could inadequate salaries secure the ‘socialist principle’ of distribution of income based on work. He launched a nationwide debate in workplaces and communities to discuss the problems of everyday life, work and efficiency that pre-occupy Cubans and their government.

Addressing Income Inequalities

So what has been happening in recent years, as the economy has been recovering, to address inequalities? In the first place, in 2005, the government raised national salaries and benefits. The minimum pension was tripled, and the minimum wage more than doubled. All salaries were then raised modestly. There is no income tax, but higher prices for electricity and food in the non-rationed food markets have eaten into the rises. Productivity bonuses have spread. In the ‘company improvement’ sector of firms given more autonomy and profit incentives, workers have seen average 30% increases in salaries. More generally by 2004/5 some 1.5 million workers were receiving productivity bonuses, often in CUCs. Such bonuses now count as part of income for calculating pensions, sick pay etc.

Other measures were aimed at reducing income inequality. Cuba ‘de-dollarised’ in 2004, making the peso and CUC the only legal currencies. In 2005 the CUC was revalued against the dollar by 8%, and a 10% exchange tax imposed, in effect an 18% tax on dollar remittances. And the national peso was also revalued to close the gap a bit with the CUC. In 2004/5 the government acted to cut out unauthorised hard currency activities by companies, and to prevent corruption in dealings with foreign firms. Also in 2005 the government sent the young social workers into the fuel distribution networks to regularise deliveries. This revealed that half of Cuba’s fuel had been going straight in to the black market! Since then other campaigns have targeted cheating consumers in peso shops. And the new progressive electricity tariff in 2006 indirectly taxes wealthy consumers, some running self-employed CUC businesses on highly subsidised peso electricity.

Raul’s insistence on 26 July that higher salaries require higher production and productivity, a commonplace of Cuban debate, raises other issues of central importance to Cuban socialism, its workers and their unions. The economy remains state-regulated, politics rules the market. Cuba’s ‘apertura’, its opening to capitalism, has been ‘Special’ and limited. Cuba did not collapse into Russian-style gangster capitalism. Nor is it ‘marketising’ along Chinese lines. But working life was changed forever by the crises of the 1990s. Full-time employment for life in a ministry-controlled enterprise has broken down. Over 90 per cent of workers are union members, but often with new types of employer: state firms in the ‘company improvement’ scheme, mixed enterprises involving foreign capital, worker co-operatives in agriculture, self-employment, and much expanded service and high-tech sectors.

Reforming Employment Relations

To take all this on board the national Labour Code – Cuba’s core employment law since 1985 – is being reformed in an extensive process of consultation, above all with the unions. This is partly to incorporate subsequent legislation, like greatly extended maternity and paternal leave. But it will also formalise the emerging post-crisis world of work. Cuba is modernising and professionalising its whole human relations culture. As Elio Valerino Santiesteban, legal head at the Central de Trabajadores de Cuba (CTC), the national union federation, put it, ‘It is a new way of thinking about human relations, and human capital as a central element of the economy.’

All of this is delaying the new Code, but in the meantime important reforms have been introduced. In 2002 health and safety at work law was strengthened, and the law on collective bargaining revised to cover new types of company. Crucially for workers and unions, collective bargaining law requires that local employment relations, and implementation of employment legislation, are negotiated with unions, with workplace assemblies having the final vote on agreements.

In 2005 a major new employment law, Resolution 8/2005, formalised equal rights for workers on part-time and other non-standard contracts. It set down workers rights in the redeployment and redundancy situations in a restructuring economy, notably the right to a new job; income protection; and education and training on full salary. Procedures for promotion and training, and recognising qualifications, were set out, tied to the worker’s right to an annual review. In 2006 new regulations covered forms of payment-by-results, shift rates and other plus payments. There is an emphasis on flexibility and productivity that we normally associate with joblessness and impoverishment. But in Cuba, on top of the protection of the legal right to work and income protection, everything has to be negotiated with the unions and accepted by workers’ assemblies, where all workers, unionised or not, vote. The new laws give unions more not less power.

Cuba is Different

A recent example is new laws on timekeeping and work discipline, erroneously described by the BBC as the new Labour Code, and by Miami sources as having provoked a revolt against Raul! The true story illustrates the strength, not the weakness of Cuban society. Resolutions 187 and 188 were announced in August 2006, for implementation in January 2007. But workers and unions argued that, while it was right to regularise the working day, it was unfair to penalise workers for being late to work, or nipping out of work. The state of public transport often made it impossible to get to work on time. And shops and public service and council offices worked the same hours as everyone else, so workers had to visit them during the working day.

So the implementation was postponed for three months, to give time to fix transport problems and negotiate new opening hours in shops and services. Of course, especially in Havana, transport could not be sorted out quickly enough. But the key point here is that implementation has to be through the collective bargaining agreement, giving unions and workers themselves an effective veto until material conditions make implementation feasible and fair. As Raul Hodelín Lugo, Secretary General of the CTC in City of Havana told me, ‘In the places where these conditions might not have been created, even though the implementation date is reached for these Resolutions, we will not agree to them being enforced. Unless the conditions exist, we cannot apply the Resolutions mechanically. The application is flexible, not mechanical. Like everything else in Cuba, we discuss with the workers.’

This is consistent with Cuba’s employment relations culture. US-inspired propaganda insists, for example, that strikes are illegal in Cuba. This is untrue. There is no legislation against strikes. There is simply no legislation on strikes. The Cuban constitution and its employment legislation embody positive rights for unions. But, unlike in most countries like the UK, the law does not regulate how unions conduct their affairs or their industrial activities. Cuba’s unions are organisationally and financially independent, but they have a constitutional right to propose, and be consulted on, labour legislation. As Dr Francisco Guillén Landrián, head of the legal section of the Labour Ministry, told me, ‘You must remember that we do nothing, absolutely nothing, until we reach agreement with our comrades in the unions. If tripartite co-ordination prevails today in any country in the world it is in Cuba, according to the International Labour Organisation.’ As for Cuba using managerial ‘human resources’ methods to sideline unions, he laughed heartily and said, ‘Whoever does that in Cuba is either suicidal or mad. We are not a society of technocrats or profit seekers. We work to satisfy peoples’ needs, and labour is a right of the people.’

Unions know that they have to work hard to make union and worker rights and participation a reality. In recent years the unions have retrained representatives at all levels, right into the workplace, especially in health and safety, and in collective bargaining. And the CTC is restructuring itself to improve its performance. So, as a new world of work emerges in Cuba’s expanding economy, Cuba’s unions remains at the heart of the political process, with the central role in developing and defending workers’ rights, rights that are indeed being strengthened in the new legislation.

Dr Steve Ludlam, University of Sheffield, has been researching employment relations in Cuba with the support of the Nuffield Foundation.
Bookmark and Share RSS