A manufactured dissident

26 July 2011

Cuba Si
The magazine of CSC
In February, Cuba broadcast Cuba’s Reasons, a five part exposé of US funded dissident groups operating on the island. Dan Smith investigates the US government’s insidious history of manufacturing opposition from within
Autumn 2013
Latin America Conference and Fiesta Latina!
Winter 2012
Inspiration from last year's Latin America Conference
Autumn 2012
Blind Cubans Going to the Movies
ALBA – The Bolivarian Alliance for the Peoples of our America
The Greatest Pain for a Father
Autumn 2012
Part II - Interview with Ricardo Alarcon, President of the Cuban Parliament
Summer 2012
A revolutionary train of thought
Keeping AIDS at Bay in Cuba
An interview with Ricardo Alarcon, President of the Cuban Parliament
Spring 2012
Sport at the heart of revolution
Summer 2011
A socialist path to sustainability
A manufactured dissident
Breaking the Silence: Beyond the Frame- Contemporary Cuban Art
Restructuring the Revolution
Spring 2011
Revealing Che’s revolutionary roots
The Doctors’ Revolution
50 years of solidarity
In Santiago it is always the 26th
Winter 2011
Gerardo remains positive
Playa Girón
Latin lessons: What can we learn from the world’s most ambitious literacy campaign?
Habana Hoy: The New Sound of Cuban Music
Autumn 2010
Sustaining the revolution
Cuba and the number of “political prisoners”
Daughter of Cuba
La revolucion energetica: Cuba's energy revolution
Summer 2010
Noam Chomsky on Cuba-US relations - exclusive
Friends of Cuba Solidarity Campaign
Waste not, want not
Miami 5 updates
Spring 2010
The real war on terror
Concert for Haiti
Cubans in Haiti
Remedios y sus Parrandas
Auntumn 2009
Interview with families of the Five
Autumn 2009
Presidio Modelo, School of Revolutionaries
Juan Almeida Bosque – hero of the revolution
Summer 2009
From here to there - Interview with Omar Puente
Pride in Cuba
Ken Gill ‘son of Cuba’
Talking to Aleida Guevara
Cuba50 - 40,000 people join the celebrations
Spring 2009
A chance encounter with Operación Milagro
Pushing for a change in UK policy
Confronting rhetoric with reality
Talking about a Revolution
Winter 2008-9
Hasta La Victoria Siempre - Interview with Cuban poet who witnessed Revolution
The revolution that defies the laws of gravity
Feminising the Revolution
Autumn 2008
Terror in Miami - Cuba's exile community
After the storm - Hurricane report
Families torn apart - Miami 5 interview
TUC Congress reports
Summer 2008
AGM Report - CSC celebrates year’s successes
Miami Five – Ten years on
Changes in Cuba?
Havana rights
Spring 2008
Fidel stands down
Celebrating 50 years of progress
Lessons for a greener world
Libraries at the heart of the community
Cuba50 – Celebrating Cuban Culture
Winter 2007/08
“In every barrio, Revolution!” - CDR Museum opens
Fighting for the Five - Leonard Weinglass interview
The World of Work in a Changing Cuba
Campaign on Barclays and extraterritoriality continues…
Autumn 2007
Interviewing Fidel
21st century medicine
The living legacy of Che
Summer 2007
From Pakistan to Rotherham:
Farewell to Vilma:
Whose rules rule?
Spring 2007
Feeding the revolution
Stop the Hilton Hotels ban
Teaching citizenship the Cuban way
Winter 06/07
Exclusive: London's Mayor visits Cuba (inglés y espanol)
Rendezvous with lies
World Circuit Records celebrates 20 years
Autumn 2006
America's favourite immigrants
Life without Fidel
The landing of the Granma
Summer 2006
Teatro Miramar: a dream to be realised
Bush’s ‘secret’ plan for Cuba
From Cuba with love: Cuban doctors in Pakistan
Spring 2006
“Hombres not Nombres”
Let there be Light
Exporting healthcare: Cuba and the real meaning of internationalism
Winter 2005-6
We are stronger than ever
Confessions of an “independent” trade unionist
Europe partakes in a recipe for disaster cooked up in Washington
Autumn 2005
Education from womb to tomb
Brendan Barber pledges TUC support for Cuba
Five reasons why the people rule
Summer 2005
Bill and Joe’s Cuban cycle adventure
Poet of Guantanamo
Participation is key to Cuba’s democracy
Spring 2005
Is Venezuela next after Iraq?
Trip of a lifetime
Justice delayed, justice denied
Winter 2004/5
Cuba's Response to AIDS
Books: Bulwark against neo-liberalism
Guide to the `Report from the Commission for Assistance to a Free Cuba´
Autumn 2004
Book review: Cuba’s story
Autumn 2004
Speaking truth to power: Cuba at the UN
Heart strings
Summer 2004
A revolution in culture
Cuba saved my daughter
Salud International to back Cuban internationalist doctors
Spring 2004
US occupation of Guantanamo Bay is illegal, says top lawyer
Miami Five: Hopeful of justice
Biotech for all
Winter 2003/4
The truth about Reporters Sans Frontières
Solar-powered education
Charting women’s progress since 1959
Autumn 2003
Join the CSC bike ride to Cuba
How the US stole Guantanamo Bay
Does the FCO website betray a political bias against Cuba?
Summer 2003
Hands Off Cuba Campaign Launched
Monument to freedom
UK lawyer visits Havana
EU lines up with US
Ibrahim Ferrer: a lesson in greatness
The Miami Five -an injustice too far
My secret mission to meet Fidel
Spring 2003
Beyond the beach and sun:
CSC’s Father Geoff Bottoms visits one of the Five
Cuban student tours UK
Autumn 2002
Moncada Day Cycle Challenge
British credit cards hit by US sanctions
Housing for the People
Summer 2002
Evil Spirit
From May Day In Havana To The Cradle Of The Revolution
A dream for all times
How foreigners fuel US anti-Cuba policy
Spring 2002
African Roots
How the US planned to start a war with Cuba
Toys for Cuba
Welsh Education Minister meets Fidel
A manufactured dissidentIt is 10 December 2010 and the damas en blanco (Ladies in White) are holding a small protest outside the Combinado del Este jail in Cuba. Laura Pollán – de facto leader of the damas en blanco – is relaying a live commentary of events to Miami-based Radio República via mobile phone:

“We have arrived without any problem at El Combinado. We are right at the entrance. Many guards are running at us.”

Pollán is being filmed by Carlos Serpa Maceira, spokesperson for various counter-revolutionary groups, reporter for Radio Marti and lynchpin of the dissident movement in Cuba. As Radio República’s listeners fear for her safety, Serpa pans to the prison’s entrance revealing the truth behind Pollán’s frightening report – there are no charging guards.

Despite this, Pollán’s words – without confirmation or verification – are reproduced ad infinitum by anti-Cuban media in Miami and the news spreads like wildfire throughout reputable Western media agencies – such as Reporters Without Borders. Within the click of a button, Pollán’s falsified account becomes uncorroborated fact. That’s how easy it is to organise a propaganda campaign against Cuba.

In Cuba’s Reasons, a fascinating five part series recently broadcast on Cuban television, however, Serpa – along with a number of other high-profile dissidents – is revealed as an undercover state operative collecting information on America’s insidious fabrication and manipulation of counter-revolutionary groups. Serpa’s secret filming at El Combinado is just one exposition of the lengths groups will go to manufacture lies to undermine the Cuban revolution. The series, Cuba’s Reasons, explores the dissident movement – sparsely populated by obsequious mercenaries – and illustrates that the United States’ strategy of subversion has evolved as the agitation for a post-Castro Cuba has been intensified.

For over fifty years, the American government has sought to undermine the Cuban revolution either overtly – through actions such as the Bay of Pigs invasion – or covertly – through the funding and co-ordination of terrorist groups and counter-revolutionary organisations. Since the 1990s, however, there has been a tactical shift in American foreign policy as work traditionally done by the CIA is now carried out by seemingly independent Non-Governmental Organisations (NGOs) such as the United States Agency for International Development (USAID) and the National Endowment for Democracy (NED). This change was encouraged and crystallised by the Torricelli Act of 1992 but the apparently autonomous NGOs continue to receive funds from federal government.

USAID was created by President John F Kennedy as a Latin American Marshall Plan and – in close association with the US Interests Section – aims to promote the fragmentation of Cuban society, organise opposition and market a negative image of Cuba internationally.

NGOs such as the Miami Medical Team Foundation, the Pan American Development Foundation and the Atlas Economic Research Foundation – all major recipients of USAID funds – are focussed on organising a national network of people to take charge in Cuba post-Castro. On a recent visit to Cuba, I met one of the undercover agents, Professor Raul Capote of the University of Pedagogical Sciences, and he spoke of how American NGOs fund scholarships abroad in places like Mexico to train the next generation of Cuban leaders. The situation parallels the States’ training of Chileans in Chicago School economics prior to the downfall of Salvador Allende’s government. Furthermore, when Fidel Castro fell ill, Capote was invited to the US Interests Section and told about the possibility of an uprising in Havana led by Dr Darcy Ferrer. Capote was asked to write an appeal calling for the support and unity of all Cubans. As history tells us, Cuba remained united in its support for the revolution.

As explained in Cuba’s Reasons, other NGOs – such as ECHO-Cuba – disguise their subversive intentions with allegedly humanitarian aid. ECHO-Cuba – ostensibly a Christian aid agency – has close links with Caleb McCarry (co-ordinator of the “Bush Plan” which sought to replace Castro) and was named in American documents as an organisation that could actively participate in the island’s democratic transition. It seems somewhat hypocritical that the US government is purportedly providing funds for aid but, at the same time, maintains an illegal and cruel blockade which denies Cubans basic resources.

All of this clandestine work is done without any democratic legitimacy and typifies American foreign policy throughout Latin America. For instance, one of the undercover agents featured in the series, Jose Manuel Collera, was approached by Otto Reich to recruit influential counter-revolutionary leaders in Venezuela to undermine the Chavez government.

America’s illegitimate interference aims to promote the image of a large, vibrant and diverse opposition movement but, as Serpa’s experience shows, this impression is largely illusionary:

“I am a manufactured dissident. My case is an example of how it is possible to make it appear internationally that a ‘great’ opposition exists here and a proliferation of anti-Castro groups … I’m national coordinator of the Julio Tang Texier Civic Cultural Project, I’m the director of the Ernest Hemingway independent library and also the director of the Union of Free Cuban Journalists, I’m the spokesman of the National Civic Resistance and I’m the spokesman of the National Civic Resistance and Civil Disobedience Front and a member of its board of directors”

US foreign policy is predicated on providing powerful incentives to foment counter-revolution and arrange provocations against Cuba. The damas en blanco are supposedly demanding the release of their relatives but, as Serpa contends, “they are a spearhead handled from abroad against the Cuban revolution” and receive payment from NGOs such as the Cuban-American National Foundation every time they organise a demonstration. Furthermore, European embassies – including Poland, the Netherlands, Czech Republic and Germany – have encouraged the undermining of Cuba’s sovereign government by providing resources, office supplies and internet access to dissident groups.

The situation is further complicated by the US Interest Section’s Refugee Program which offers further inducement to invent and exaggerate opposition. According to Serpa, anyone wanting to leave Cuba “has to provide evidence to the Refugee Section that they are being harassed by the Cuban government, they invent ‘arguments’ in order to obtain a visa”. As a result, wannabe economic migrants are obliged to reinvent themselves as active counter-revolutionaries and Serpa was frequently asked by members of the damas en blanco to provide evidence of their dissident activities for the Refugee Program so they could leave Cuba:

“They were always chasing up photographs showing them on their demonstrations because the Program demands that of them … all the women who go there take photos … and that’s a strong testimony for the US Interest Section”.

According to Moisés Rodríguez, another undercover agent, the independent journalists, human rights activists and oppositionists are not motivated by a love of Cuba but “they are all servile annexationists and mercenaries. They always have two things in mind: number one, to receive money; and number two, to leave Cuba”.

This highlights the inherent contradiction at the heart of US policy towards Cuba. On the one hand, they are urging people to emigrate to demonstrate the lack of support for the revolution but, on the other hand, they don’t want counter-revolutionaries they have created to leave because then they will be left without any protagonists with whom to execute their subversive plans.

Therefore, the domestic counter-revolution in Cuba is neither an authentic nor spontaneous phenomenon but rather the expression of the anti-Cuban policy encouraged by the United States through a network of groups, institutions and organisations. This subversive strategy seeks to create local hotbeds of tension, fabricate leaders and portray the misleading image of an organised local opposition in Cuba. The campaign seeks to isolate Cuba through the distortion of its reality, accusing the Cuban government of violating human rights and democratic freedom. In truth, it is American imperialism – through a thinly-veiled shroud of supposedly independent NGOs – which is seeking to undermine a sovereign government whilst reinforcing a barbaric and unjust blockade.
TOP
Bookmark and Share RSS